| | Amigo League Standings by Year |
| | 2012 |
| | Gammons | W | | L | | RF | | RA | | Mgn |
| | Pittsburgh | 100 | | 62 | | 858 | 657 | | 201 |
| | Pasadena | 99 | | 63 | | 866 | 678 | | 188 |
| | Echo Park | 90 | | 72 | | 782 | 698 | | 84 |
| | Mendocino | 51 | | 111 | | 588 | 919 | | -331 |
| | LeMaster | W | | L | | RF | | RA | | Mgn |
| | Honcut | 84 | | 78 | | 747 | 778 | | -31 |
| | Lihue | 83 | | 79 | | 825 | 767 | | 58 |
| | Dodge City | 67 | | 95 | | 741 | 870 | | -129 |
| | Austin | 51 | | 111 | | 670 | 934 | | -264 |
| | Weaver | W | | L | | RF | | RA | | Mgn |
| | PA | 102 | | 60 | | 892 | 636 | | 256 |
| | Gold City | 88 | | 74 | | 754 | 695 | | 59 |
| | Lehigh | 82 | | 80 | | 791 | 778 | | 13 |
| | Baltimore | 75 | | 87 | | 763 | 868 | | -105 |
| | 2011 |
| | Gammons | W | | L | | RF | | RA | | Mgn |
| | Echo Park | 102 | | 60 | | 798 | 612 | | 186 |
| | Mendocino | 81 | | 81 | | 736 | 807 | | -71 |
| | Pittsburgh | 78 | | 84 | | 759 | 770 | | -11 |
| | Pasadena | 73 | | 89 | | 789 | 821 | | -32 |
| | LeMaster | W | | L | | RF | | RA | | Mgn |
| | Austin | 97 | | 65 | | 862 | 715 | | 147 |
| | Dodge City | 84 | | 78 | | 800 | 742 | | 58 |
| | Lihue | 78 | | 84 | | 760 | 774 | | -14 |
| | Honcut | 70 | | 92 | | 670 | 742 | | -72 |
| | Weaver | W | | L | | RF | | RA | | Mgn |
| | Baltimore | 88 | | 74 | | 900 | 794 | | 106 |
| | Springfield | 88 | | 74 | | 818 | 810 | | 8 |
| | Lehigh | 73 | | 89 | | 793 | 877 | | -84 |
| | PA | 60 | | 102 | | 705 | 926 | | -221 |